Raising a 'genderless' baby?!

  • Tuesday, May 24, 2011 1:41 PM
    Message # 600227
    Debbi (Administrator)
    The Toronto Star ran an article this weekend about a couple who are raising their 4-month old as 'genderless' i.e. not telling it or anyone if it's a boy or a girl. They also have two sons - the parents believe they are giving their children the freedom to choose who they want to be, unconstrained by social norms about males and females.

    You can read the article here - http://www.parentcentral.ca/parent/babiespregnancy/babies/article/995112--parents-keep-child-s-gender-secret

    This seems crazy to me - what is the point?



  • Tuesday, May 24, 2011 9:00 PM
    Reply # 600670 on 600227
    Denise (Administrator)
    Debbi Wong wrote:The Toronto Star ran an article this weekend about a couple who are raising their 4-month old as 'genderless' i.e. not telling it or anyone if it's a boy or a girl. They also have two sons - the parents believe they are giving their children the freedom to choose who they want to be, unconstrained by social norms about males and females.

    You can read the article here - http://www.parentcentral.ca/parent/babiespregnancy/babies/article/995112--parents-keep-child-s-gender-secret

    This seems crazy to me - what is the point?




    Being parents is way more challenging than ever.  Though we have a lot of information and resources teaching us to be better parents, there is more pressure nowadays especially if you want to pass some "good virtues" to your children. 

    I guess one day we don't have to teach our children anything because "they shouldn't have been molded into something that they might not want to be". 

    Our society is getting more and more ridiculous!

     

  • Tuesday, May 24, 2011 9:19 PM
    Reply # 600706 on 600227

    I was really disturbed all weekend by this article.  So much so that I felt the need to comment on The Star website itself.  Unfortunately, I couldn't say everything I wanted to say because of character restricitions but here was what I posted:

    "I'm just a little confused as to why these parents found it necessary to raise a genderless child? I have a little 2 year old girl and she wears both girl and boy clothes and plays with whatever toys she wants. She'll grow up as a girl knowing she can play with whatever she likes, cut her hair whatever way she likes, and ultimately love whomever she wants. She can make these choices wearing a dress or pants. It doesn't matter! What these parents are telling their children is that it DOES matter what you wear or what you play with so you should be gender-neutral to be accepted otherwise, you might be called gay or girly. That's sad. I'm also really concerned the kids aren't in a formal school. One that is recognized by employers in their future. they will forever be dependent on their parents for everything. One of their sons already doesn't want to deal with school. What will he do when he's not accepted as an adult? Run home to mommy and daddy and be (s)he? Great. Good job."

    I subsequently replied to others' comments with the following:

    "To those who said it's no one's business how these parents raise their children. Uh, they out their story in a national paper. They made it our business. We can comment as much as we like. You're as disturbing as hey are! For the transgender woman in KS. I admire your response and appreciate your struggle but the article isn't about boys that want to be transgender. It's about their parents forcing transgender-ism onto them without their having a choice. It's different than what you went through. I would understand a boy stating they were born a girl, despite their body. It's not the same thing."

    It is difficult to understand the motivation behind the choice these parents are making.  It's already such a confusing world to live in and I'm concerned overall about these children and their ability to live and work in society in the future. 

  • Monday, May 30, 2011 9:39 PM
    Reply # 608925 on 600227
    You guys might learn something by reading the mother's response.  
    ie. what the point is...  

    http://www.vancouversun.com/Storm+responds+vitriolic+attacks/4861024/story.html

Our Community

Life With A Baby
LWAB Foundation

Our Partners







Click here to visit this Mount Sinai's website

© 2020 Life with A Baby, Inc. All Rights Reserved.